Showing posts with label IHSS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IHSS. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 29, 2010

IHSS, Round 2

Governor Schwarzenegger tried to keep people with conviction history out of the care provider industry before, but he was blocked by the courts.  So he's going after it again--this time, in partnership with the LA Times.  A fitting partnership, I must say, given the paper's track record in fear-mongering against people with conviction history.

The current law already prohibits an IHSS recipient from employing her family member through the program if the family member has been convicted of child abuse, elder abuse, or Medicare fraud in the past 10 years.  The law does not care if the family member completely turned his life around, or if he may be the best caregiver for the IHSS recipient.  The 10-year ban is absolute.  Cal. Wel. & Inst. Code section 12305.81.

And the IHSS program is already set up to give the recipients the freedom and duty to screen whom they choose to care for them.  The existing law exempts IHSS agencies from liabilities arising out of the conduct of caregivers they refer to recipients.  Cal. Wel. & Inst. Code section 12301.6(f).

With this setup, individual recipients must follow existing laws on hiring people with conviction history.  For example, under California's Investigative Consumer Reporting Agencies Act (ICRAA), background check companies cannot report convictions older than 7 years.

If the laws change (as proposed by Governor Schwarzenegger) then the Department of Social Services would be exempt from the ICRAA provisions and will consider old convictions too, substituting its judgment for the judgment of recipients as to who is best qualified to provide care for them.

Needless to say, advocates are already working hard to make sure that rational deliberation wins over irrational fear-mongering.  (Thank you, Jessie!)  Here's hoping and praying that California legislators are more level-headed than LA Times reporters.

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

UPDATE: IHSS background check

Peter Sheehan of Oakland-based Social Justice has been working in the field of background check laws for over 3 decades. And he has done some amazing work. Earlier this year, he helped me with removing a sex offender registration requirement for a client of mine, who had been adjudicated in a juvenile court of sexual penetration with a minor (while he himself was a minor, sheesh). Now, Peter has come through in a big way for so many people of low income that depend on IHSS payments. Below is an excerpt from his email to me this morning.
[W]e have a preliminary in IHSS litigation (Ellis v. Wagner) enjoining DSS from continuing to carry out its policy of asking for or disqualifying IHSS providers or potential providers due to felony or serious misdemeanor until a final hearing on the merits in late January. From the brief argument I think the high probability of success swung the court on the preliminary so that is a good sign for January.
Way to go, Peter!

UPDATE: The San Francisco Chronicle published an article about the case.

Monday, October 19, 2009

IHSS background check

A client of mine came out of prison about a year ago and is well on her way to sobriety and rehabilitation. She currently part-time works as an assistant at a sober living house and has supplemental income from another part-time gig as a caretaker for a couple of old people as a provider of in-home supportive services (IHSS). She's not making a whole lot of money, but she can make do without any government assistance because of these part-time jobs.

She contacted me last week to ask about a letter she received from the California Department of Social Services. It's called IHSS Program Provider Enrollment Form. It asks her, among other things, about her criminal history, stating that any conviction for elder abuse, fraud against a public benefit program, and/or child abuse will disqualify her from continuing her work as an IHSS provider. This is a problematic policy, mandated by California Welfare & Institute Code § 12305.81, because it disregards the potential negation of the seeming nexus created by the above-listed crimes. More problematic is that the Form goes one step beyond what the law mandates and states, in addition, that:
If you have EVER been convicted of a felony crime OR certain serious misdemeanor crimes, you are NOT eligible to be enrolled as a provider or to receive payment from the IHSS program for providing supportive services.
I have no idea where this "no-felony" rule comes from, and I'm trying to track it down. But I have this suspicion that it's made up by the Department of Social Services. And, now that it's in their official Form, I fear that this is and will continue to be their policy. Once again, the supposed "need" for criminal background check outweighs a rational and reasonable consideration of nexus and negation.

UPDATE (10/28/2009): I can't yet disclose where, but a reliable source informed me that the State's argument appears to be that W&I 12305.81 must be construed as simply adding additional grounds for disqualification to W&I 14123, which grants the Department of Social Services (through its director) the authority to suspend payment to people convicted of felony and/or misdemeanor related to duties, functions, and qualifications of the applicable Medi-Cal program.

One of the most obvious problems with this argument is that IHSS is not Medi-Cal. In addition, the source also referred me to W&I 12301.6(e)(5)(B)(ii), which allows a recipient of either IHSS or Medi-Cal benefits to hire a person with criminal history, as long as the history doesn't include any disqualifying offense under (yes, we're now back to) W&I 12305.81.

I am sitting this one out, because I learned that it's already in the hands of a very capable attorney. Good to have good peeps.